TÜV отчет 2006 - победители и проигравшие в борьбе за качество

По итогам TÜV (техосмотр) был проведен анализ надежности 185 самых популярных автомобилей, допущенных к движению по немецким дорогам.

Результаты предоставлены в простой и удобной форме: возрастная категория и количество машин с выявленными серьезными дефектами в процентном соотношении к общему количеству одинаковых моделей.

Возраст автомобиля
2-3 года     4-5 лет      6-7 лет      8-9 лет     10-11 лет

  2-3 года (средний показатель: 6,6%)
Место Производитель и
модель
Квота машин
с серьезными
поломками
1 Subaru Forester
3,0 %
2. Mazda Demio
Toyota Yaris
3,4%
4. Porsche 911
Toyota Corolla
3,5%
6. Porsche Boxster
3,6%
7 Mercedes SLK
Subaru Legacy
3,8%
9. Mazda MX-5
3,9%
10. Mercedes A-Klasse
4,0%
11. Toyota RAV 4
4,1%
12. Mercedes C-Klasse
4,2%
13. Ford Fiesta
Opel Corsa
VW Polo
4,3%
16. Audi A4
4,5 %
17. AudiA2
BMW 7er
4,7%
19. Honda Civic
Mazda Premacy
4,8%
21. Nissan Primera
VW Golf/Bora
4,9%
23. Volvo S60
VW New Beetle
5,0%
25. Nissan Almera
Toyota Avensis
5,1%
27. Mitsubishi Colt/Lancer
Saab 9-3
5,2%
29. Audi A3
Honda Accord
Land Rover Freelander
Mitsubishi Space Wagon
Skoda Fabia
5,3%
34. AudiTT
5,4%
35. Mazda 626
Mercedes SL
Opel Agila
Smart Fortwo
5,5%
39. Ford Focus
5,6%
40. Citroen Berlingo
Suzuki Wagon R
5,7%
42. Citroen Xsara
Mazda 323
Mitsubishi Pajero
Suzuki Jimny
5,9%
46. Mitsubishi Carisma
6.0%
47. Mitsubishi Galant
6,2 %
48. VW Lupo
VW Passat
6.3%
50. Seat Leon/Toledo
Skoda Octavia
6,4%
52. BMWZ3
Ford Mondeo
6,6%
  Renault Megane
Suzuki Swift
6,7%
57. Audi A8
Volvo V70
6,8%
59. Audi A6
6,90%
60. Citroen C5
Mercedes S-Klasse
Suzuki Vitara
7,0%
63. BMW 3er
Seat Ibiza/Cordoba
Volvo S40/V40
7,1%
66. Hyundai Atos/Atos
Prime Renault Scenic
7,2%
68. Renault Twingo
Renault Clio
7,3 %
70. BMW 5er
7,40%
71. Peugeot 206
Peugeot 307
7,5%
73. Nissan Micra
7,60%
74. Fiat Seicento  
Kia Sephia
Volvo S80
7,7 %
77. BMWX5
7,90%
78. Ford Ka
8,00%
79. Mercedes M-Klasse
8,10%
80. Fiat Punto
8,20%
81. Hyundai Elantra
8,40%
82. Alfa 147
Renault Espace
8,5 %
84. Lancia Y
8,60%
85. Fiat Stilo
Opel Vectra
8,7%
87. Jeep Grand Cherokee
8.8%
88. Opel Omega
8,90%
89. Daihatsu Cuore
Mini
9,0%
91. Renault Kangoo
Seat Arosa
9,3%
93. Alfa 156
Mercedes EKlasse
9,4%
95. Citroen Saxo
Peugeot 106
9,8%
97. Opel Zafira
10,10%
98. Peugeot 406
10,60%
99. Hyundai Accent
10,70%
100. Chrysler PT Cruiser
10,90%
101. Chrysler Voyager
Ford Galaxy
11,0%
103. Opel Frontera
11,20%
104. Seat Alhambra
11,50%
105. VW Sharan
12,70%
106. Fiat Marea
13,70%
107. Renault Laguna
14,80%
 
    4-5 лет (средний показатель: 17,2%)
1. Mercedes SL
4,10%
2. Porsche Boxster
4,40%
3. Mazda MX-5
4,80%
4. Audi A2
4,90%
5. Mazda Demio
5,30%
6. Mercedes SLK
Toyota RAV 4
5,60%
8. Toyota Yaris
5,70%
9. Toyota Avensis
5,80%
10. Porsche 911
6,00%
11. Subaru Forester
6,20%
12 Nissan Almera
6,30%
13. Subaru Legacy
6,70%
14. Honda Accord
7,00%
15. Toyota Corolia
7,10%
16. Mercedes S-Klasse
Mitsubishi Space Wagon
7,20%
18. Opel Agila
Suzuki Baleno
7,90%
7,90%
20. Volvo S40/V40
8,00%
21. AudiTT
Misubishi Pajero
VW Golf/Bora
8,20%
24. Mercedes C-Klasse
8,30%
25. Nissan Primera
8,40%
26. Mazda Premacy
8,50%
27. Saab 9-3
8,70%
28. Audi A3
8,80%
29. Ford Focus
Smart Fortwo
9,30%
31. Honda Civic
9,40%
32. Suzuki Vitara
Volvo S80
VW Polo
9,50%
35. VW New Beetle
9,70%
36. Citroen Xantia
9,80%
37. Skoda Fabia
9,90%
38. Mitsubishi Carisma
10,00%
39. Suzuki Jimmy
10,10%
40. Mazda 626
Seat Leon/Toledo
Skoda Octavia
10,30%
43. Seat Ibiza/Cordoba
10,40%
44. Audi A4
Mercedes M-KlasseVW Lupo
10,50%
47. Opel Vectra
10,60%
48. Opel Corsa
10,70%
49. Mercedes E-Klasse
Nissan Micra
10,80%
51. Mitsubishi Colt/Lancer
Opel Astra
Suzuki Swift
10,90%
54. Ford Mondeo
Mazda 323
11,00%
56. BMW 5er
11,30%
57. Audi A8
11,40%
58. Fiat Punto
11,50%
59. Renault Clio
11,70%
60. Peugeot 406
Seat Arosa
11,90%
62. BMWZ3
Ford Fiesta
Hyundai Atos/Atos Prime
12,00%
65. Citroen Xsara
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Peugeot 206
VW Passat
12,20%
69. Lancia YVolvo V70
12,40%
71. Audi A6
Peugeot 306
12,50%
73. Mercedes A-Klasse
Renault Megane
12,60%
75. Renault Laguna
12,70%
76. BMW 7er
12,90%
77. Daihatsu Cuore
13,00%
78. Citroen Berlingo
13,20%
79. Opel Omega
13,30%
80. Alfa 156
13,40%
81. Hyundai Accent
Renault Espace
13,50%
83. Nissan Serena
14,00%
84. Land Rover Freelander
14,10%
85. Mitsubishi Galant
14,30%
86. Fiat Marea
14,40%
87. Opel Zafira
14,70%
88. BMW 3er
Fiat Bravo/Brava
14,8%
90. Renault Twingo
Renault Scenic
15,2%
92. FordKa
15,90%
93. Fiat Seicento
16,10%
94. Opel Frontera
Peugeot 106
16,40%
96. Hyundai Lantra
16,50%
97. Citroen Saxo
17,10%
98. Renault Kangoo
VW Sharan
17,40%
100. Ford Galaxy
Suzuki Wagon R+
17,50%
102. Kia Sephia
18,20%
103. Seat Alhambra
18,40%
104. Alfa 145/146
20,30%
105. Fiat Palio Weekend
23,70%
106. Chrysler Voyager
27,30%
 
    6-7 лет (средний показатель: 22,7%)
1. Porsche Boxster
Porsche 911
5,8%
5,8%
3. Toyota Corolla
7,10%
4. Mercedes SLK
Toyota RAV 4
7,2%
6. Mazda MX-5
7,30%
7. Toyota Starlet
Toyota Avensis
7,4%
7,4%
9. Subaru Legacy
Subaru Forester
8,6%
11. Nissan Almera
8,70%
12. Mercedes SL
8,80%
13. Mazda 323
9,30%
14. Mitsubishi Space Wagon
10,20%
15. Suzuki Vitara
10,40%
16. BMWZ3
11,20%
17. Honda Civic
Mitsubishi Colt/Lancer
Suzuki Baleno
11,7%
20. Saab 9-3
11,80%
21. VW Golf/Bora
12,10%
22. Citroen Xantia
Mazda 626
VW Polo
12,2%
25. Audi A3
VW Lupo
12,4%
12,4%
27. Mitsubishi Galant
13,20%
28. Opel Corsa
13,40%
29. Nissan Primera
13,50%
30. Smart Fortwo
13,60%
31. Honda Accord
Mitsubishi Pajero
13,90%
33. Nissan Micra
14,00%
34. BMW 7er
Land Rover Freelander
14,1 %
36. Daihatsu Cuore
14,20%
37. Mercedes C-Klasse
14,50%
38. Opel Astra
14,80%
39. Seat Arosa
Skoda Octavia
15,0%
41. Volvo S40/V40
15,10%
42. Seat Ibiza/Cordoba
15,30%
43. Volvo 940/960
15,50%
44. Opel Vectra
15,60%
45. Mercedes A-Klasse
16,00%
46. Hyundai Atos/Atos Prime
16,20%
47. Ford Mondeo
Mercedes E-Klasse
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Renault Espace
16,3%
51. Mercedes S-Klasse
Peugeot 406
Renault Laguna
16,4%
54. Suzuki Swift
16,50%
55. Opel Frontera
Volvo S70/V70
17,0%
57. Citroen Xsara
17,20%
58. BMW 5er
17,40%
59. Renault Scenic
18,10%
60. Audi A6
Hyundai Lantra
18,3%
62. Mitsubishi Carisma
Nissan Serena
18,4%
64. Peugeot 306
18,50%
65. Peugeot 106
18,80%
66. Hyundai Accent
Renault Megane
19,2%
68. Audi A8
19,3%
69. Audi A4
Ford Scorpio
19,8%
71. Alfa 156
19,9%
72. VWSharan
20,2%
73. Lancia Y
20,3 %
74. Fiat Punto
20,5%
75. Seat Alhambra
20,6%
76. Fiat Seicento
Fiat Bravo/Brava
20,7%
78. VW Passat
20,9%
79. Ford Galaxy
21,1%
80. Seat Toledo
21,2%
81. BMW 3er
Ford Fiesta
21,3%
83. Citroen Saxo
Mazda 121
21,4%
85. Ford Escort
21,5%
  Kia Sephia
21,5%
87. Opel Omega
21,6%
88. Fiat Marea
23,0%
89. Alfa 145/146
23,4%
90 Skoda Felicia
23,7%
91. Ford Ka
24,1 %
92. Citroen Berlingo
24,6%
93. Suzuki Wagon FT
24,8 %
94. Renault Clio
25,1 %
95. Chrysler Voyager
29,6 %
96. Fiat Palio Weekend
30,9%
97. Renault Twingo
34,3 %
 
    8-9 лет (средний показатель: 22,7%)
1. Porsche 911
6,5%
2. Mercedes SL
7,7%
3. Toyota RAV 4
8,4%
4. Toyota Starlet
8,8%
5. Toyota Corolla
10,0%
6. Mazda MX-5
12,0%
7. Subaru Legacy
12,2%
8. Nissan Almera
Toyota Carina
13,8%
10. BMWZ3
14,0%
11. Suzuki Baleno
14,5%
12. Mitsubishi Colt/Lancer
15,0%
13. Mitsubishi Space Wagon
15,9%
14. Mazda 626
Mercedes S-Klasse
16,2%
16,2%
16. Honda Civic
16,4%
17. Audi A3
16,6%
18. Volvo 940/960
16,9%
19. Opel Corsa
17,2%
20. Mercedes C-Klasse
17,3%
21. Suzuki Vitara
17,4%
22. Mazda 323
17,5%
23. Mercedes E-Klasse
17,8%
24. Peugeot 406
17,9%
25. Opel Frontera
18,3%
26. Opel Vectra
19,0%
27. Daihatsu Cuore
19,1%
28. Honda Accord
19,3%
29. Audi A8
19,4%
30. Mitsubishi Pajero
19,6%
31. Citroen Xantia
19,7%
32. Mitsubishi Galant
Suzuki Swift
19,9%
1
34. Jeep Grand Cherokee
VW Polo
20,2%
36. OpelAstra
20,6%
37.BMW 7er
20,7%
38. Volvo 850
21,3%
39.Nissan Micra
21,5%
40. VW Golf/Vento
21,8%
41. Seat Ibiza/Cordoba
22,1 %
42. Nissan Primera
22,2%
43.Audi A6
BMW 5er
VW Sharan
22,9 %
46. Citroen Saxo
23,0%
47. Mitsubishi Carisma
23,5 %
48. Ford Galaxy
VW Passat
23,7%
50. Hyundai Lantra
24,1%
51. Peugeot 106
24,7%
52. Fiat Bravo/Brava
Peugeot 306
25,0 %
54. Audi A4
25,20%
55. Ford Mondeo
25,30%
56. Mazda 121
25,40%
57. Renault Laguna
25,60%
58. Ford Ka
25,80%
59. Ford Scorpio
26,00%
60. Lancia Y
26,30%
61. Skoda Felicia
26,70%
62. Ford Fiesta
26,80%
63. Opel Omega
27,20%
64. Ford Escort
27,60%
65. BMW 3er
Hyundai Accent
27,7%
67. Fiat Punto
28,10%
68. Fiat Marea
28,70%
69. Kia Sephia
28,90%
70. Fiat Cinquecento
29,80%
71. Renault Espace
30,50%
72. Renault Clio
Renault Megane
30,9 %
74. Chrysler Voyager
31,50%
75. Seat Toledo
32,20%
76. Citroen ZX
32,30%
77. Alfa 145/146
36,20%
78. Renault Twingo
37,10%
 
    10-11лет (средний показатель: 27,6%)
1. Porsche 911
8,70%
2. Mercedes SL
9,40%
3. Mercedes S-Klasse
14,20%
4. Mazda MX-5
14,60%
5. Toyota Corolla
15,10%
6. Subaru Legacy
15,80%
7. Toyota Carina
16,10%
8. Mercedes C-Klasse
16,80%
9. Toyota Starlet
17,10%
10. Suzuki Vitara
17,90%
11. Mercedes E-Klasse
19,10%
12. Volvo 940/960
21,00%
13. Mazda 121
21,60%
14. Honda Civic
22,20%
15. Mitsubishi Space Wagon
Mitsubishi Pajero
22,3%
17. Daihatsu Cuore
23,20%
18. BMW 5er
23,50%
19. Mitsubishi CoK/Lancer
23,60%
20. Suzuki Swift
24,30%
21. Mitsubishi Galant
24.4%
22. Honda Accord
24,60%
23. Mazda 323
25,00%
24. BMW 7er
25,40%
25. Opel Corsa
25,50%
26. Volvo 850
25,60%
27. Citroen Xantia
Mazda 626
26,0%
29. Nissan Micra
Opel Vectra
Opel Frontera
26,3%
26,3 %
26,3%
32. Opel Astra
26.4%
33. Hyundai Lantra
26,80%
34. Audi A6
26,90%
35. VW Golf/Vento
27,30%
36. VW Polo
27,50%
37. Nissan Primera
28,40%
38. VW Passat
28,50%
39. Audi 80
28,90%
40. Opel Omega
29,30%
41. Ford Scorpio
29,50%
42. Fiat Cinquecento
Ford Fiesta
Peugeot 405
29,8%
45. Peugeot 306
30,30%
46. Peugeot 106
30,60%
47. Ford Mondeo
30,90%
48. BMW 3er
31,80%
49. Seat Ibiza/Cordoba
32,40%
50. Kia Sephia
32,70%
51. Ford Escort
34,40%
52. Renault Espace
34,80%
53. Fiat Punto
35,00%
54. Renault Laguna
35,50%
55. Renault 19
36,50%
56. Renault Twingo
Renault Clio
37,9%
58. Citroen ZX
38,10%
59. Seat Toledo
41,20%